A simulation study to compare different estimation approaches for. Methods all randomized trials of radiotherapy rt with or without chemotherapy. An introduction to network metaanalysis mixed treatment. Heterogeneity was assessed by calculating tau 2 and i 2 and was considered low, moderate and high for i 2 values of 60. Background the conduction and report of network metaanalysis. Comparative efficacy and acceptability of 21 antidepressant drugs for the acute treatment of adults with major depressive disorder. Metaconnectomic analysis reveals commonly disrupted. Nma, we imputed the relevant treatment effect and its standard error in software r and used a. Our aim was to give an overview of the evidence network regarding the efficacy and safety of tdcs and to estimate the effectiveness of the different. Methods from graph theory usually used in electrical networks were transferred to nma. The statistical theory behind network metaanalysis is nevertheless complex, so we strongly encourage close collaboration between dental researchers and experienced statisticians when planning and conducting a. In more detail, the resulting consistent treatment effects induced in the edges can be estimated via the moorepenrose pseudoinverse of the laplacian matrix. Chaimani a, higgins jpt, mavridis d, spyridonos p, salanti g graphical tools for network metaanalysis in stata anna chaimani 0 julian p.
However the relation between a and b is only known indirectly, and a network metaanalysis looks at such indirect evidence of differences between methods and interventions using statistical method. Methods from graph theory usually used in electrical networks were. A graphical tool for locating inconsistency in network metaanalyses. A network metaanalysis comparing the efficacy and safety. Preoperative hair removal and surgical site infections. The netmeta package is based on graph theory methodology to model the relative treatment effects of multiple. Network metaanalysis is an extension of standard pairwise metaanalysis that can be used to simultaneously compare any number of treatments.
There are available strategies to address aggregate mod, and in particular binary mod, while considering the missing at random mar assumption as a starting point. Comparing two approaches to multiarm studies in network metaanalysis. All statistical analyses were conducted using sas statistical software version 9. The netmeta package in r is based on a novel approach for network metaanalysis that follows the graphtheoretical methodology. In estimating a network metaanalysis model using a bayesian framework, the rjags package is a common tool. All analyses will be performed using the r software version 3. Network metaanalysis of randomized trials on the safety. Oral anticoagulants in atrial fibrillation with valvular. Network metaanalysis was performed with r software version 3. Frequentist network metaanalysis using the r package. Network metaanalysis for decisionmaking takes an approach to evidence synthesis that is specifically intended for decision making when there are two or more treatment alternatives being evaluated, and assumes that the purpose of every synthesis is to answer the question for this preidentified population of patients, which treatment is best.
Forest plots are not so easy to draw for networks multiarm trials make everything more complicated but. The estimated overall effect sizes, test for heterogeneity, moderator effects, and publication bias were reported using r software. It has been found to be equivalent to the frequentist approach to network. Association of gleason grade with androgen deprivation. Automated methods to test connectedness and quantify indirectness. Transcranial direct current stimulation tdcs is an emerging approach for improving capacity in activities of daily living adl and upper limb function after stroke.
A network metaanalysis on the effects of information and. Network metaanalysis is an active field of research in clinical biostatistics. A network metaanalysis of nonsmallcell lung cancer. A network metaanalysis toolkit cochrane comparing multiple. The network graphs package in stata contains 8 commands that produce graphs for network metaanalysis. We conducted a network metaanalysis using two approaches. Development of restricted mean survival time difference in.
Some of the commands are used combined with the mvmeta command. Because basic metaanalysis software such as revman does not support network metaanalysis, the statistician will have to rely on statistical software packages such as stata, r, winbugs or openbugs for analysis. However, it remains unclear what type of tdcs stimulation is most effective. In network metaanalysis most of the information comes.
Cipriani, andrea, toshi a furukawa, georgia salanti, anna chaimani, lauren z atkinson, yusuke ogawa, stefan leucht, et al. Graph theory concepts are used to study and model social networks, fraud patterns, power consumption patterns, virality and influence in social media. The statistical methodology underpinning this technique and software tools for implementing the methods are evolving. Efficacy and safety of approved firstline tyrosine kinase. Let x k k1,m denote the observed effects and v k the corresponding variances. A network metaanalysis comparing the efficacy and safety of antipd1 with antipdl1 in nonsmall cell lung cancer. Comparison of exclusion, imputation and modelling of. Scientific collaboration network business ties in us biotechindustry genetic interaction network proteinprotein interaction networks transportation networks internet. A primer on network metaanalysis for dental research. Network metaanalysis, electrical networks and graph theory. The network components are idealized of physical device and system, order in to for them to represent several properties, they must obey the kirchhoffs law of. Here are some books focused on brain network, which may provide some insights on how to do network metaanalysis. Terminology in metaanalytic networks and electrical networks.
Network metaanalysis also known as multiple treatment comparison or mixed treatment comparison seeks to combine information from all randomised comparisons among a set of treatments for a given medical condition. Graph drawing, as part of the mathematical concept of graph theory, has extensively been used in many research disciplines, such as social network analysis, electrical networks, biology. A graphtheoretical approach to network metaanalysis. The individual patient data from the metaanalysis of chemotherapy in nasopharynx carcinoma database were used to compare all available treatments. Network metaanalysis is a generalisation of pairwise metaanalysis that compares all pairs of treatments within a number of treatments for the same condition. It aims to combine information from all randomized comparisons among a set of treatments for a given medical condition. Network metaanalysis for decision making will be of interest to decision makers, medical statisticians, health economists, and anyone involved in health technology assessment including the pharmaceutical industry. We run the simulation study in the freely available software r 2. Methodology from electrical networks and graphic theory also can be used to fit network metaanalysis and is outlined in by. A simulation study to compare different estimation. An electrical network is a collection of components and device interconnected electrically. Advanced statistical methods to model and adjust for bias in metaanalysis version 0. In this study, a network metaanalysis was performed to synthesize existing research comparing the effects of different types of cai versus the traditional instruction ti on students learning achievement in taiwan.
Graphical tools for network metaanalysis in stata pdf. The graphtheoretical method for analysis of network metaanalyses uses graphtheoretical methods that were originally developed in electrical network theory. Network metaanalysis, electrical networks and graph. These graphs can be used to present the evidence base, the assumptions and the results of a network metaanalysis and aim to make the methodology accessible also to nonstatisticians. This method exploits the analogy between treatment networks and electrical networks to construct the network metaanalysis model accounting for the correlated treatment effects in. The use of network metaanalysis has increased dramatically in recent years. Winbugs, a freely available bayesian software package, has been the most widely used software package to conduct network metaanalyses. Social network analysis sna is probably the best known application of graph theory for data science. In the image, a has been analyzed in relation to c and c has been analyzed in relation to b.
A network metaanalysis looks at indirect comparisons. Limitations in the design and flaws in the conduct of studies synthesized in network metaanalysis nma reduce the confidence in the results. Network metaanalysis nma is becoming increasingly popular in systematic. Purpose the role of adjuvant chemotherapy ac or induction chemotherapy ic in the treatment of locally advanced nasopharyngeal carcinoma is controversial. A microsoftexcelbased tool for running and critically. Most complex systems are graphlike friendship network. Network metaanalysis for decisionmaking statistics in. Graphical tools for network metaanalysis in stata open. Software for network metaanalysis gert van valkenhoef taipei, taiwan, 6 october 20. An example was used to demonstrate how to conduct a network metaanalysis and the differences between it and traditional metaanalysis. A graphtheoretical approach to network metaanalysis graphs and networks consist of nodes and edges connecting them adjustment for multiarmed studies this is a special requirement in network metaanalysis example conclusion gerta r.
It is used in clustering algorithms specifically kmeans. Despite these recommendations and the recent development of software statistics. Finally, we used a metaanalysis to demonstrate network dysfunctions across neuropsychiatric disorders. In network metaanalysis most of the information comes from indirect evidence. A network metaanalysis of nonsmallcell lung cancer patients with an activating egfr mutation. Network metaanalysis synthesizes direct and indirect evidence in a network of trials that compare multiple interventions and has the potential to rank the competing treatments according to the studied outcome. Based thereon, we then show that graphtheoretical methods that have been routinely applied to electrical networks also work well in network metaanalysis. The objective of this study is to describe the general approaches to network metaanalysis that are available for quantitative data synthesis using r software.
Frequentist network metaanalysis using the r package netmeta. This network metaanalysis aims to deliver an uptodate, comprehensive efficacy and toxicity comparison of the approved firstline tyrosine kinase inhibitors tkis for metastatic renal cell carcinoma mrcc in order to provide support for evidencebased treatment decisions. Based thereon, we then show that graph theoretical methods that have been routinely applied to electrical networks also work well in network metaanalysis. One confounding factor was the sample heterogeneity in our metaanalysis created by the various subtypes of depressive disorder e. An introduction to graph theory and network analysis with. Network metaanalysis was performed with r software, version i386 3. Higgins 0 dimitris mavridis 0 panagiota spyridonos 0 georgia salanti 0 0 1 department of hygiene and epidemiology, school of medicine, university of ioannina, ioannina, greece, 2 school of social and community medicine, university of bristol. Statistical software has been developed to fit network meta. Development of restricted mean survival time difference in network metaanalysis based on data from macnpc update. Automated methods to test connectedness and quantify. Terminology in metaanalysis and electrical networks. Network metaanalysis of randomized trials on the safety of vascular closure devices for femoral arterial puncture site haemostasis skip to main content thank you for visiting.
480 909 480 87 1462 444 169 930 877 676 931 1180 596 918 683 1068 238 1412 1149 1446 1087 965 574 507 853 1052 870 1050 448 487 271 129